In class writing – what are the three liars?

After finishing the book, I found the three liars, Mirren, Gat and Johnny, were ghosts, just in my perspective.

First of all, they kept thinking about and talking about things that Cadence didn’t know. For example, Cadence didn’t know their model before Summer 17; she couldn’t just imagine something that already existed. Also, Mirren told with Cadence about how she jealous about Gat’s love to Cadence. I didn’t really think Cadence would imagine the whole thing by herself that she wouldn’t know Mirren’s thinking. The jealousy between people wasn’t that easy to think of, and if Mirren didn’t tell, Cadence would never noticed about it. Also, the liars went to the sea by motorboat with Cadence, I didn’t think it can be done by herself. The liars never went out to see others, but if they were just imagination, Cadence can actually imagine that they went out together with others to do something and she wouldn’t get confused. If they were just imagination, their actions wouldn’t be that restrained, and they should be able to do whatever Cadence wanted them to instead.

I thought they were ghost, and just came back to Cadence because she needed help. Cadence didn’t want to admit the truth they already dead, and she couldn’t really realize without them. At least the liars appeared in the story should be their spirit. Then they could help Cadence to fix the problems and the big mess of the whole family.